🎬 Logan (2017) • Neo-Western Superhero Drama • Watched on Disney+
Why I Watched: Putting this on in honor of Sir Patrick Stewart’s memory (and seeing his heartbreaking farewell to Charles Xavier alongside Hugh Jackman) hit me harder than ever tonight.
Intro: I love this; stripping away the shiny spandex for a dusty, R-rated neo-Western turns a comic-book movie into a raw story about aging and fatherhood.
The Director’s Eye (What Worked):
• Sir Patrick Stewart breaks my heart playing a fragile, 90-year-old Charles Xavier wrestling with dementia and regret, while Hugh Jackman and an 11-year-old Dafne Keen share a fierce, unspoken bond.
• John Mathieson’s sun-bleached border deserts, rusted smelting-plant shadows, and neon motel rooms make 2029 feel lived-in and weary.
• Finally letting the adamantium claws tear through the Reavers with R-rated, bone-crunching weight (where every hit leaves Logan limping and scarred) grounds the fights in real pain.
• James Mangold leans into classic Shane and Unforgiven Western framing while Marco Beltrami’s sparse, aching piano and ambient strings haunt the road trip.
The Friction (What Didn’t Click for Me):
• Bringing in X-24 as a younger, feral clone of Logan for the physical brawls trades some of the grounded Western grit for a literal “fighting himself” comic-book trope.
• Once Dr. Zander Rice shows up in the third act to deliver a speech about slipping mutant-suppressing corn syrup into the food supply, the villain side loses the scrappy menace Boyd Holbrook’s Donald Pierce had early on.
Standout Moment: That quiet, warm dinner around the Munson family farmhouse table where Charles finally gets to enjoy one normal evening of peace and family…and tells Logan what a good night feels like.
Through My Lens: Leaning into Methodism, watching a weary Logan care for an ailing Charles in the desert and lay down his life so a child made as a weapon can know grace reminds me that we are never defined by the violence of our past; honoring our elders and choosing sacrificial love gives the next generation a chance at peace.
The Verdict: 8.7/10
I love it. Watch this if you want an emotional, neo-Western masterpiece and a towering performance from Sir Patrick Stewart. Skip it if you want a cheerful, family-friendly X-Men team-up without heavy grief and R-rated brutality.
★★★★½


Leave a Reply